Monday, October 20, 2014

In defense of IVF and fertility treatments


Sometimes when I read articles about assisted reproductive technology I make the mistake of reading the comments.  While I shouldn’t find the judgment and hostility surprising—“trolls” make nasty little comments on a slew of topics—I still feel the need to offer some defense of the use of fertility treatments such as IVF.

Some of the comments focus on the obvious—fertility treatments are expensive.  They suggest that money could better be used elsewhere.  Fair enough, but that’s true of just about everything.  Do you have cable?  Go out to eat?  Go on vacation?  Fine, spend your money how you want.  Don’t judge how I spend mine.  (Although I must admit a portion of my treatments have been covered by insurance.  In that way I am lucky, but I would have made the exact same choices with my own money.)

Others make the argument that infertile couples should just adopt.  Again, fair enough, and many couples do make that choice.  But as anyone who has adopted, or looked into adopting, can tell you, it’s no cakewalk.  Like fertility treatments, adoption is expensive.  Like fertility treatments, adoption is stressful.  And like fertility treatments, adoption might not work out.  Adoption is not the right choice for everyone, and I don’t think it’s wrong to want to have biological children, be pregnant, be guaranteed a newborn, or any of the other reasons people choose to try to have biological children instead of adopting.  Also, I find the whole “there are so many kids looking for homes, so just adopt” argument a little hard to swallow coming from anyone who hasn’t made the choice to adopt.  The fact that there are lots of kids that need homes is true whether someone is dealing with infertility or not.  (Along these lines, I have no patience for the “world population is too large” arguments either.  Again, that’s true whether the parents are fertile or infertile.  And, see my comments below on fertility treatment parents being the best kinds of parents—ones who want kids.)

Likewise, I can’t engage with or take seriously anyone who goes on the rampage about fertility treatments being “unnatural.”  Yea, so is brushing your teeth. Vitamins.  Chemo.  Get over it.

Instead of attacking people who decide to use fertility treatments, we should be celebrating people who really, really want to be parents.  I believe most people who try this hard to be parents and ultimately succeed are really good parents….  Probably better parents than the judgmental assholes trolling articles and making anonymous mean comments.

Sunday, October 19, 2014

Predictions….


I pre-wrote this post.  As optimistic as I initially was about my hatchling, I was going to say I don’t think it worked.  No implantation bleeding.  (A very, very, very tiny amount of old brown dried blood a few days after the procedure, but I could have been because the doc accidentally pinched my inner lady bits during the procedure.)  My sore boobs do not appear in the morning until I take my estrogen.  No nausea.
BUT, I had one last pesky pregnancy test floating around in my bathroom.  A really nice one—a Clearblue digital.  And I thought, what the heck?  So 8dp6dt (8 days after my 6-day hatched embryo transfer) and two days before my scheduled blood test, I took the plunge.  PREGNANT!  I had to read the result (which says “PREGNANT”) three times before I believed it.  Yay!
BUT THEN the next day (24 hours after the test and 24 hours before my blood test) I started having very strange bleeding.  STOP READING NOW IF YOU DO NOT LIKE TMI.  I’ve had implantation bleeding before—it was like a really, really light period that just lasted half of a day.  And at least for the one kid who actually made it to the end, it was the day before my blood test confirming the pregnancy.  So the timing of this seems like it could be implantation bleeding.  But it’s not the same as last time.  It’s, frankly, gross.  Imagine a tablespoon of chocolate chips blended up into a tiny chunks slurried with someone’s snot.  That’s what it’s like.  Super dark (black/brown).  Snotty and clotty.  Seems a little gritty.  I actually had a small clot.  It lasted maybe a day and was about 2-3 tablespoons or so in volume.  But it was freakin’ gross. 
So, where does that leave us?  I guess it could be implantation bleeding.  (Especially if it stops.) The dark color suggests that it’s old blood (red is new blood).  So that’s good.  (Active miscarriages tend to be the red blood, not brown.  But the brown blood can also be a sign of an impending miscarriage or an ectopic pregnancy.  *Shudder.*)  I’ve also read that the kind of progesterone I am on—crinone (a change in protocol from my last FET cycle)—can cause some spotting/discharge.  If I hadn’t taken a pregnancy test, I would have taken it as a good sign—potential implantation bleeding.  But having had my BFP, it’s a little unnerving to see chunks.
So let’s not get too excited just yet.  I’ve been pregnant FIVE times and yet I only have one kid.  I know as much as anyone that getting pregnant is only the first step in the process.  And the miscarriage rate for frozen embryos is really high, with better quality embryos less likely to miscarry:
(Although this study is from 2006, based on data from 1997-2001, and I think freezing technology is getting better and better.)  So I just have to accept that I have a VERY good chance of miscarriage.  Whether it’s already started or whether this one is going all the way, only time will tell.

Saturday, October 18, 2014

Embryo reduction


One of the main reasons my husband and I have chosen (four times!) to do only a transfer of a single embryo is because we do not want to have twins.  And I obviously spent a significant amount of time yesterday going on and on about how risky twin pregnancies can be.  But if we ultimately do end up pregnant with twins, we would be very happy and we would make it work.
Many people undergoing fertility treatments welcome—or even want—twins.  But a very, very small number of people who use fertility treatments and get pregnant with twins choose to reduce the twin pregnancies to single pregnancies (ie. selectively abort one of the fetuses).  See a NY Times article on the subject:
I’m pro choice.  But there is something uncomfortable about going through all of this, purposefully getting pregnant, and terminating one half of a generally healthy twin pregnancy.*  Nevertheless, I can’t judge a person’s choice to reduce a twin pregnancy to a single pregnancy.  It is not the choice I think I would make for myself, but I’ve never been in that position.  And even if I were, and I made the choice to keep both (which I think I would), it’s not my job to tell other people how to live their lives. 
But for people—like us!—who do not twins, single embryo transfer is an option, and one I hope more and more potential IVF parents consider.  On that note, here’s a link to an article in support of selective single embryo transfer (from a success perspective and a financial perspective):
*I can completely understand reducing higher order pregnancies, as they are so very dangerous to the babies and mom.

Friday, October 17, 2014

Twice as nice?


As I’ve already mentioned, we decided to go with one embryo again.  It’s a very daring choice, as our embryos are all B3s and there is a less than 20% chance any individual embryo of that quality will result in a baby.  I suspect most couples would opt for two, as that increases the chance that you get a baby to about 40%.  Of course, the rate of twins with two B3s is about 15%. 
I’ve been very vocal about not wanting twins, but I would take twins over no kid at all.  On that point, there’s a nice article defending twin pregnancies from IVF:
I should also note that some women who do a single embryo transfer still manage to find themselves pregnant with twins.  And if that happens, you know it’s because the embryo split and you’re having identical twins.  OMG.
My doctor made an interesting comment that made me think about identical twins—he suggested that use of a “hatching” blastocyst is slightly more likely to result in identical twins.  Assisted hatching (using a laser to help it hatch) of day 5-6 blastys also has been associated with an increased risk of identical twins.  (I’ve read that is not necessarily true with 3 day implantations.)
For “natural” (non-IVF) identical twins, the rate is about 3/1000 births.  So 0.25-0.5%.  Pretty rare.  IVF increases the risk (or incidence, if we’re not being all anti-twin) of identical twins.  Specifically, I have seen suggestions that identical twins in IVF births are about 2%.
Identical twins do not “run in families” like fraternal twins do.  (I.e. there is no genetic component to egg splitting as opposed to producing extra eggs.)  There is an association with older mothers—the older the mom, the more likely there is to be egg splitting and thus identical twins.  The theory is that an older mom’s shell that the blasty hatches from is harder, making the inner mass break into clumps.  Poor older moms!  So maybe the increased identical twin risk in IVF relates to the population doing it (old moms) and maybe there really is something to the process of IVF (I’ve read articles that seem to think the latter is true).
Interestingly, the split can occur anytime in the early part of the process.  An “early” split (like before day 4) usually forms identical twins that will not share a placenta.  (That is good.  More on that later.)  Most twins split around day 4 or 5.  Interestingly, twins formed during this time can be “mirror images” of each other.  (So one has a mole on her right cheek, the other has the same mole in the same place on the left cheek.)  Twins that split later—days 9/10—mean that they will probably share the same sac.  (No good.)  That only happens about 1% of the time.  Even later splits (days 13-15) mean the twins might be conjoined.  Very rare, also no good.  [Fyi, I got all of my information from Wikipedia, so please feel free to give it as much weight as you feel is appropriate.]
Some thoughts on twins….  Okay, obviously many people (like us) who do IVF and opt for a single embryo transfer do it because we do not want twins.  I know what you’re saying, “twice as nice!”  Yes, but there are a lot of risks with twin births.  They are harder on mom.  Much harder on mom.  Mom gains a lot more weight, and is at greater risk for a host of health issues such as pre-eclampsia (30% in twin pregnancy, 2-10% in singleton pregnancy), gestational diabetes (12% versus 4%), and Caesarean-section.  They are also much harder on the babies.  Twins are usually not full term, tend to have a lower birth weight, often spend time in the NICU, and are at risk for more health issues such as cerebral palsy (affects 4-6 times as many twins compared to singletons).  And I cannot even imagine the terror of twin newborns, toddlers, teenagers, etc.  The horror, the horror.
And things only get worse with identical twins.  Not only are there the same risks with identical twins as there are with fraternal twins, but there are even more potential problems!  Identical twins that do not share the same placenta (early splitters) are just like fraternal twins.  That’s the safest kind.  But once they start sharing the placenta, there’s the risk of sharing blood, and that is dangerous and can lead to death.  Things only get worse if they share a sac, as their cords can get entangled, etc.
Links to articles about identical twin risks from IVF and dangers of those pregnancies:

Thursday, October 16, 2014

Time for sexy time?


So, as you know, once you go down the IVF path, sex no longer has any procreative value…. Or does it?  At least one study has suggested that semen can significantly promote embryo development and implantation:


“Intercourse during an IVF cycle has the potential to improve pregnancy rates since exposure to semen is reported to promote embryo development and implantation in animals. Conversely, coitus-induced uterine contractions or introduction of infection may have a detrimental effect.”

So have sex, just don’t like it, especially after your procedure.

IF we do this again, I’m going to make it a priority to have sex before the transfer….  Which is actually a bigger chore than it sounds because the gross progesterone suppositories start before transfer.  There is NOTHING is sexier than white, creamy, hormones coming out of your va-jay-jay, amIright ladies?

Wednesday, October 15, 2014

Mo’ aging, mo’ problems


Obviously I’m disappointed that our two B3s from our first round (when I was 32) did not survive.  (Have I mentioned that there was a lab issue that resulted in the frozen ones from our last cycle being ruined?)  So we’re doing a frozen cycle with our 35-year old guys.  Boooooo.  The rates of down syndrome DOUBLE from a 32 year old to a 35 year old mom.  There is nothing good about getting old when it comes to fertility.  Really, old hags like me should be shitting themselves when considering fertility statistics (handily collected for us from labs around the country):


Check out the national averages.  Okay, they’re not too bad for 36 year olds….  At the clinic we are using, about 40% of the women my age get pregnant and take home at least one kid, at least in any individual frozen or fresh cycle.  Not great, but not the kiss of death either.

At what I have read is one of the best lab/Dr. offices in the country, they have CRAZY good odds:


(Of course some offices patient shop or report numbers in a certain way, so they specifically warn you to take these with a grain of salt.  Still, SUPER interesting.)  Note that they are doing WAY more frozen cycles than fresh.  I bet they do pre-genetic testing on a lot of those.  But those stats! 43% of women over 42 doing a frozen cycle had a kid!  That’s insane!  (Of course these are women who managed to do a fresh cycle, have at least something reach blastocyst, presumably have those blastocysts tested and pass, and then have whatever they froze survive the thaw.  So those embryos went through the gauntlet.  I’m also going to guess that a fair number of those were frozen before the mom was 42.  But still, that’s amazing!)

What am I worried about?!  I’m a spring chicken.

Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Freezer burn

As I mentioned earlier, at my lab about 85% of the blastocysts that are frozen (they only freeze blastocysts) survive the thaw.  That’s pretty good.  Interestingly, they suggested that the blastys that survive the thaw have better odds than the fresh of the same rating, probably because the freezing process weeds out more of the weak ones. 

Unfortunately, the miscarriage rate tends to increase with the frozen embryos.